This Thanksgiving, Big Food thankful for vetoed food safety law
Alfonso Soler - stock.adobe.com.
Faced with rampant food safety gaps and harmful chemicals concentrated in the state’s food supply, Governor Hochul vetoes bipartisan-backed bill
Today, Governor Kathy Hochul vetoed the Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act (S1239F/A1556G), landmark legislation that would ban the use of several harmful food additives and mandate new transparency requirements for chemical use in food products sold in New York. In the face of lax FDA regulation, the bill would have helped address a decades-long loophole that allows food suppliers to sneak untested chemicals into their products and independently certify ingredients as “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS).
Jensen Jose, Senior CSPI Regulatory Counsel, issued the following statement in response:
“Right before Thanksgiving, Governor Hochul vetoed a bill to make New Yorkers’ food safer. At a time when Secretary Kennedy, President Trump and Congress have failed to deliver meaningful food safety reform, New York had a chance to lead the nation. Governor Hochul’s veto hands the food industry a victory at the expense of New York families, allowing inflated industry cost claims to stand in the way of commonsense food safety protections. In a sea of federal deregulation where children and families are ingesting hidden, harmful chemicals, New Yorkers are forced to keep fishing through a maze of unsafe products without the information they need to guide their purchases. Food companies insist they’ve done the safety testing already. New York lawmakers were just asking them to show their work.
The Center for Science in the Public Interest will continue to fight for New Yorkers’ right to safe, nutritious food, alongside our coalition of dedicated community and health leaders. We commend our prime sponsors—Senator Brian Kavanagh and Assembly Member Dr. Anna Kelles—and both houses of the State Legislature for passing this bill. We are confident that next session lawmakers will put the health of New Yorkers first.”
Food giants are successfully hijacking a decades-old federal loophole to introduce harmful chemicals into the nation’s food supply without adequate FDA oversight. Consumers are increasingly concerned about the FDA’s failure to protect consumers from harmful chemicals in supplements and foods. Recent data confirms that more than 70% of American adults are alarmed about chemicals in the food supply, and 5 in 6 want government and businesses to do more on chemical safety and transparency. Without state-level reform, children and families remain susceptible to rampant corporate secrecy and weak federal food safety protocol.
Last month, the Center for Science in the Public Interest ran a five-figure ad campaign featuring pizzamakers Frank Pinello and John Gristina, and mothers Liuba Grechen Shirley, Pastor Sharmaine Byrd, and Afsana Haque urging the Governor to sign the bill to protect customers and families statewide.
Background
The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act (S1239F/A1556G): Ends the secrecy of a federal loophole that allows companies to self-designate their ingredients as “generally recognized as safe” or GRAS without adequate FDA oversight. The bill prohibits the use of three harmful additives in foods sold statewide and requires companies to disclose evidence confirming the safety of food chemicals that bypass the FDA’s safety review. By mandating transparency requirements for chemical use in foods and eliminating unsafe additives, the bill aims to improve health outcomes and protect New York consumers from health harms like cancer and developmental delays.
The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act offers New York an opportunity to lead in protecting its residents—especially children—from preventable harm. According to new polling, 87% of New Yorkers want fewer harmful chemicals in their food, underscoring strong public support for reform. In addition to the New York State American Academy of Pediatrics, more than 170 small businesses and community organizations statewide have endorsed the bill, along with 107 physicians who argue that transparency reform could cut down on rising healthcare costs.
The bill is critically important because a proposed GRAS rule drafted by the FDA to require such notification was stripped down during White House review, reportedly under the leadership of former Trump Chief of Staff Susie Wiles. That rendered the proposed reforms unenforceable by ensuring there are no direct consequences for companies that fail to share safety data with the FDA. The FDA proposal also does not require FDA review prior to marketing.
Researchers from Tufts and the Center for Science in the Public Interest published a study debunking industry’s claim that the bill will cost millions of dollars. The Tufts/CSPI study estimated the legislation would cost at most a one-time $28 per New York household—even assuming companies pass 100 percent of the cost to consumers, an unlikely event.
This largely due to industry overestimates of conducting new safety testing, a step companies insist they have already done under existing federal requirements. The opposition lobby also spread other types of misinformation about the bill, misrepresenting how it will impact workers and small businesses, which are exempted from the legislation. These concerns and misinformation are easily addressed, paving the way for passage and signature of the bill in the next legislative session.
Why Food Safety Regulation Is Urgent:
- Dangers in the Nation’s Food Supply: Americans are regularly exposed to food chemicals that have been banned throughout the European Union, Canada, China, and other countries due to known health risks. Additives like Red No. 3, potassium bromate, and propylparaben have been linked to cancer, hormone disruption, and other serious conditions—yet they remain legal and widely used in most U.S. states.
- Federal Inaction: According to a 2024 American Journal of Public Health analysis, the FDA rarely re-evaluates or revokes GRAS status, even as new research raises concerns about the safety of long-approved chemicals. Simultaneously, the FDA’s food safety program has been severely weakened by ongoing layoffs and structural reforms, limiting its ability to inspect, regulate, or enforce food safety standards.
- Chronic Disease Risk: With rates of cancer, developmental disorders, and hormone-related illnesses on the rise, public health experts have warned that continued exposure to toxic food additives could further exacerbate health inequities and drive long-term costs to the healthcare system. The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act offers New York an opportunity to lead in protecting its residents—especially children—from preventable harm.
# # #
Tags
Topics
Contact Info: Adaku Nwokiwu, 347-455-8121, adaku@pythiapublic.com