Correcting the industry’s inflated cost estimates for the New York Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act
GRAS economic analysis by Tufts University and Center for Science in the Public Interest
Abstract
New York’s Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act (S1239F/A1556G) would require manufacturers to report publicly available information used to determine that ingredients are “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS) and ban three food chemicals linked to adverse health outcomes. Widely reported industry estimates, commissioned by the American Beverage Association (ABA) and written by Policy Navigation Group (PNG), grossly overstate the cost of this legislation to NY consumers and the food industry. Correcting just two flawed assumptions substantially reduces the estimated cost: (a) the industry estimates wrongly assume massive new data collection costs, even though manufacturers should already possess the scientific evidence required to support their GRAS determinations under existing federal law, and (b) the industry estimates assume that manufacturers would withdraw products that have sales too low to justify compliance costs, but then use vastly higher sales figures when calculating the subsequent costs to consumers. Correcting just these two estimates reduces the PNG cost estimate from $4.88 billion to $1.11 billion, a 77% reduction. Correcting an additional seven flawed or unsupported assumptions reduces the estimated cost to $219 million, 96% less than the PNG estimate. PNG assumed that nearly all of these estimated costs would be passed on to NY consumers, but this assumption is inconsistent with the economic literature they cite. The PNG estimate is fundamentally flawed and should not be used as the basis for public policy decisions.
View the resource linked below to keep reading.